What Is a Tube Mascara + Our Top 5 Picks

By PMUHub Editorial Team| Last updated on July 17, 2023
tube mascara
⏱️ 6 min read

If you’ve been on TikTok recently, you must have come across a video about tube mascara. It looks like magic – it doesn’t smudge at all; it just slides right off the lash! But how does that work? Is it worth a try?

Let’s find out!

What Is a Tube Mascara?

It’s a product that works just like a regular mascara, but has a different, more resistant formula which ensures your lash look stays put.

If you’ve ever worn mascara you know how annoying it can get when it smudges – it can ruin your whole look!

And the worst part is that you have hardly any control over it. If you laugh so much your eyes get teary or step out into the rain without an umbrella, you may end up looking like a panda.

This is because most mascaras use oil or wax as a base. As long as it’s dry, everything’s fine, but as soon as it comes in contact with some moisture… it’s all over.

Tube mascara has a formula of polymers that coat individual lashes rather than painting layers on top of them – like a tube. This makes it more resilient.

Tube Mascara Removal

If it’s so sturdy, how does it come off then?

Easier than regular mascara! All you need to do is get a damp washcloth or cotton pad (or even a finger), and apply a downward motion on your lashes – it’ll slide right off!

@katiehub.org also, the formulas are different- should i make a video about that as well? #fyp #mascara #tubingmascara ♬ Elevator Music - Bohoman

Our Faves

Now that we’ve seen what you can achieve with tube mascara, let’s take a look at some great ones you can try out! Here are our top picks for the best tubing mascara:

Blinc Amplified Tubing Mascara

This product is great for those with sensitive skin or eyes since it doesn’t contain talc, paraben, gluten, or sulfate. It also contains no oils, so you can be sure that it won’t smudge. The formula is also completely cruelty-free!

You can find it in a wide range of brush shapes to fit your preference. Also, if you’re more in the mood for a dark brown tubing mascara, Blinc’s got you covered!

Tarte Tartelette Tubing Mascara

On top of offering a life-proof formula that is resistant to flakes and smudges, the Tartelette tubular mascara also contains lash-conditioning shea butter, castor oil, and carnauba wax.

It’s vegan, gluten-free, and cruelty-free, and comes in recyclable packaging, giving you peace of mind.

It comes in a travel size as well, so if you’re just looking to try it out before committing to a full tube, this is the right option for you!

Caliray Come Hell or High Water Mascara

This product offers you security not only in its water-resistant tubing formula but also in the fact that it’s also vegan and recyclable! The formula is also infused with argan oil, which serves as a lash conditioner, nurturing from root to tip!

If you’re looking to pair the smudge-free mascara with other resilient eye products, Caliray is also offering sets, so you can get your hands on some waterproof eyeliner as well at a reasonable price!

Essence Tubing Mascara

Speaking of reasonable prices, Essence has become known for their drugstore tubing mascara. Their product, delightfully named Bye Bye Panda Eyes, has gone viral on TikTok since the very beginning of the trend.

This is no surprise since it serves its function perfectly while simultaneously being PETA-certified as a brand that doesn’t test on animals. You can start your lash routine with Essence’s primer to achieve even more volume!

Kevyn Aucoin Tubing Mascara

This tubing mascara, on top of the smudge-free technology, features Jojoba oil in its formula that adds shine to the lashes. Depending on what kind of look you want to achieve, there are two options you can choose from.

The first is the volume brush, which helps you be more precise with the application, and the second one is the curling brush which adds more length to the lashes.

Is It Worth Buying?

Yes! The main benefit of tubing mascara is that there are no smudges, as we’ve already explained.

Thanks to that, it can last all day long. What’s more, it also looks more natural compared to regular mascara since there are no layers of ink that can make you look a bit cakey.

The downsides are that it’s actually a bit wetter than normal oil or wax-based mascara at first. It also takes longer to dry, but, if you ask us, it’s worth the 30-second wait.

FAQs About Tube Mascara

Now that we’ve covered the basics and given some suggestions, let’s answer some of the most common questions about tubing mascara!

Can I Apply It Over Lash Extensions?

No. You shouldn’t apply tube mascara on top of lash extensions because removal, although easier, still requires some friction, which could damage the extension.

Can I Just Use a Waterproof Mascara Instead?

While waterproof mascaras should prevent smudging, you’re still at risk of having it crumble and flake.

This doesn’t happen with tubing mascara. However, the tubular mascara gives you a more natural look, so if you’re a fan of more dramatic looks, waterproof mascaras could be a better option.

Can I Remove Tube Mascara with Regular Makeup Removers?

Regular makeup removers, such as micellar water, aren’t as effective at removing tube mascara. You’ll still need to slide it off with a pad, washcloth, or finger.

Can I Apply Multiple Coats of Tubing Mascara?

Yes, but this can cause clumping. Tubing mascaras are already known for creating length, so layering may not even be necessary. If you still want to add something, you can combine it with a volumizing mascara.

Is Tubing Mascara More Expensive?

It depends on the brand. You can see with the products we listed above that the price range varies just like with regular mascara. So, if you’re just looking to test it out, there are cheaper options to get you started.

Can I Use a Lash Curler with Tubing Mascara?

Yes, but curl them before applying the mascara to avoid accidentally taking the tubes off with the curler. These mascaras are even known for holding curls better than regular ones!

How Do I Apply the Tubing Mascara?

Just like any other – start at the root, wiggle the wand upwards, and then wait for it to dry.
Reminder – tube mascaras dry a little longer than normal ones.

Can a Tubing Mascara Cause Irritation or Allergic Reaction?

There aren’t any irritating ingredients in tubing mascara formulas, but if you have sensitive eyes, it’s best to check the ingredient list before applying. After all, not all tubing mascara formulas are identical to each other.



Exclusive insights into the PMU industry right in your inbox.

FREE newsletter. 100% good stuff.